This is a web page preview of a Microsoft Word document from the The Alliance Party of Northern Ireland site. It is generated by a computer and is not manually edited. Formatting and content may be displayed differently to the original document, and should not be regarded as definitive.


Alliance Works

Alliance Party of Northern Ireland

Manifesto for the

Northern Ireland
Assembly Elections

26November 2003


Introduction

1. Governing a Shared Northern Ireland

2. Building a United Community

3. Strengthening Our Economy

4. Taking Responsibility for Finance

5. Justice and a Culture of Lawfulness

6. Realising Potential through Education

7. Health and Social Services for a Better Life

8. Protecting Our Environment

9. Supporting All in Our Society

10. Revitalising Our Culture, Arts and Leisure


Making Devolution Work

This election should be about bread and butter issues, and what an Assembly can do for you.

Our devolved Assembly has given the people of Northern Ireland the opportunity to choose their own future. Decisions can now be taken, policies implemented, and legislation passed which are much more responsive to the needs of the people that they affect.

In recognition of this new opportunity, Alliance is issuing its most detailed manifesto for any election. It has been shaped through a wide consultation with Party members, representatives of the business, voluntary and community sector, and most importantly, ordinary citizens.

Building a united community and creating a shared future lie at the heart of the Alliance policy agenda. Tackling the divisions within our deeply divided society must be the greatest priority for our political institutions. Unless we seriously address these problems, they will eventually destroy the Agreement and all that has been achieved so far.

The Assembly is also the representative voice of the people of Northern Ireland—in dealings with the United Kingdom, both centrally and in the devolved nations and regions; the Republic of Ireland; the European Union and even further afield.

Alliance is looking forward to the time when policing and criminal justice functions can be transferred to the Assembly. We have included a substantial section on justice and the rule of law, issues on which we will lobby the Government until responsibility for justice is devolved. It is a matter of great concern that Northern Ireland lags so far behind the rest of the UK in this area.

Sectarianism and segregation carry considerable human and financial costs. We have identified hundreds of millions of pounds wasted in needless duplication of facilities to cater for separate demands. These resources could be put to much greater use in improving public services.

Devolution offers so much potential, but instead we have had five years of wasted opportunities.

The record of the parties in the Executive to date has not been impressive. Even allowing for the stop-start approach to devolution, they have made little difference to people's lives. Much of the legislation introduced by Ministers has been merely copied from Westminster, with little consideration of local needs and concerns. Decisions on some of the most pressing issues facing Northern Ireland have been postponed.

Most importantly, those charged with the responsibility of Government have not even begun to address the biggest problem—the continued deep divisions within our society.

Making the Agreement Work

However, this election is also about restoring trust and confidence in the political process.

In 1998, people voted for a new beginning. While in many respects Northern Ireland is better than it was a decade ago, the progress that people had a right to expect over the past five years has not occurred. Instead, the Unionist and Nationalist parties have wasted time with their continued squabbling and failures to implement the Agreement.

Rather than working together for the good of all, they have pursued their own narrow agendas and have bickered over issues like policing reform.

Even today, rather than looking to a shared future together, the UUP and SDLP are moving to the extremes, looking over their shoulders at the DUP and Sinn Fein.

The Agreement remains the only way forward to peace and stability in this society. The demands from others for `renegotiation' are completely unrealistic. We cannot allow others to rip it up and start all over again.

Instead, Alliance will push for positive changes to make the Agreement work better for all. Our priorities will be to:

Alliance — Making the Difference

Alliance is the political voice of those who work to create a united community, one characterised by sharing, not separation. We offer everyone an invitation to join something different, something better than tribal politics — a genuinely shared and non-sectarian future.

Only Alliance rejects the notion that we must all be pigeon-holed into `two communities', only Alliance respects personal choice over identity.

The Alliance alternative is an open, free and fair society, where we are all equal citizens — not a society where we merely tolerate difference, but rather a society where we celebrate diversity and cherish individuality.

We can achieve this vision within the Agreement, an updated and better Agreement. For Alliance, the Agreement is not the ceiling of our ambition. It is the foundation on which we can create a better future.

I hope you share our vision and can support our action plan for Northern Ireland, as presented in the following pages. Every first preference vote will help us as we work to realise a better future for all of us.

0x01 graphic

David Ford
Party Leader


The Agreement

Alliance reiterates its full support for the Good Friday Agreement. The Agreement represents an historic accommodation among the various political traditions in Northern Ireland, north and south, and all of these islands. Its major strength continues to be the creation of a set of political institutions with cross-community legitimacy within a deeply divided society. The Agreement also provides the opportunity to discuss and develop some fundamental aspects of a shared society, like human rights, equality and social justice.

Yet the implementation of the Agreement has been undermined by continued bickering among the pro-Agreement parties and their failure to rise above narrow sectarian concerns to work for the common good. At the outset, the Agreement was seen as a win-win by all sections of the community. Sadly, it is today regarded in zero-sum terms, with a gain one for one section of the community being perceived as a loss by another.

Most crucially, we have witnessed a deterioration in community relations and an increase in sectarianism, racism and segregation on the ground. Regrettably, the Agreement has played a major role in contributing to an institutionalised sectarianism in Northern Ireland.

Comprehensive Review

Several years on, it is possible to view the Agreement and its implementation from a clearer and more critical perspective. Over the past five years, these deficiencies and flaws in the Agreement have come into much clearer focus.

Fortunately, the Agreement does provide the terms for its own comprehensive review. It is now necessary to review its terms and structures, and to learn the lessons of experience.

This will not be a renegotiation, but rather improvements to the working of the Agreement, firmly based on the principles of the Agreement.

Alliance's proposals for the Comprehensive Review are rooted in the party's key values:

The `constitutional issue' is not a defining issue that preoccupies the Alliance Party. In keeping with the three core values the party's main concern is that the people's consent is paramount and that the legitimate interests of all are safeguarded.

Alliance is firmly committed to the principle of power sharing. We favour a move away from the rigid, consociational form of power sharing contained in the original Agreement, towards more flexible and integrated versions of power sharing more appropriate for an evolving and diverse society. Ultimately, our objective is to fashion Northern Ireland as a model European liberal democracy.

Alliance Proposals for the Review

Before the commencement of the scheduled formal Review of the Agreement, Alliance will be presenting a detailed paper setting out our proposals for making the Agreement work better. Our full proposals will include the following:

Constitutional Status

Alliance restates its support for the Principle of Consent. Alliance believes that the people of Northern Ireland should not be restrained from devising and advocating any constitutional outcome, not merely a straight choice between the maintenance of the United Kingdom or a united Ireland.

Size of the Assembly

Alliance believes that the Assembly is too large, and consequently too expensive. Alliance will support moves to reduce the size of the Assembly.

Designations and Voting System

Alliance is concerned at the sectarian nature of the Assembly designations and related voting system. It is crucially important that, in a deeply divided society, significant matters in the Assembly are decided on a cross-community basis. However, there are several different forms of cross-community voting, not confined to the two versions in the Agreement. There are four particular problems with the current system:

Alliance strongly advocates the use of a weighted majority, free from any communal designations, for key decisions in the Assembly.

The Executive

The NI Executive has not performed as expected. Much of this is due to poor design. Through an involuntary coalition, there is no requirement or incentive for parties to abide by collective responsibility. Ministers can run their Departments as personal fiefdoms. There is little scope for removing a Minister who is underperforming or who is politically inept.

Alliance argues that the Executive should be formed as a voluntary power-sharing coalition, endorsed by a weighted majority vote in the Assembly to ensure a cross-community composition. It should be possible for parties to negotiate a balanced executive, with an agreed programme for government. This would be required to achieve a cross-community weighted-majority vote in the Assembly in order for it to come into effect.

Office of First Minister and Deputy First Minister

Alliance advocates the abolition of the current Office of First Minister and Deputy First Minister, to be replaced by a more streamlined office, with appropriate functions being reallocated to dedicated Departments.

The First Minister would fulfil the normal functions of a chief minister, chair meetings of the executive, and provide a representational service. A Deputy First Minister would deputise for the First Minister.

Ministerial Accountability

To date, Ministers in the Northern Ireland Executive have been able to take decisions within their own area of responsibility with little or no political checks and balances, and only the minimum protections provided by law. At the same time, the Statutory Committees have not been as effective as envisaged.

Alliance proposes to give the Assembly the power to nullify a Ministerial decision, through a weighted majority vote.

Committee Chairs

The d'Hondt system is a poor form of proportionality that is prone to major distortions. Alliance would replace the d'Hondt system for allocating Chairs of Committees, with a fairer and more effective system, where such a mechanism is required. One possibility would be via an STV election by the MLAs.

NI Assembly and Oireachtas

There is a need for more openness and transparency within the North-South Ministerial Council. Alliance believes that the Taoiseach and Tanaiste, First Minister and Deputy First Minister should make a joint report on the NSMC activities in each of the respective legislatures every year.

Alliance also believes that the Assembly and the Oireachtas should be required to establish a North-South Parliamentary Tier, open to all parties, with each jurisdiction sending equal numbers of participants.

Promoting Community Relations

Community relations must be given a higher profile following the Review of the Agreement.

Alliance proposes to place a statutory obligation on public authorities to carry out functions with due regard to the need to promote good relations between all sections of society. This would be of a similar nature to the current equality duty.

Human Rights

Alliance stresses our continued support for the work of the NI Human Rights Commission. There is a concerted attack on the Commission from both Nationalists and Unionists. The Commission is hampered by ambiguous mandate, related to the `two communities'.

Alliance believes that the NIHRC should be given a clear remit to devise a Bill of Rights to protect individuals, minorities and communities in Northern Ireland.

Definition of a Ceasefire

The Government has maintained a distinction between a ceasefire and a cessation of all violence; Alliance has not. This distinction should be closed. Paragraph 13 of the Joint Declaration should be the basis of any definition of an end to all paramilitary activity:

“Paramilitarism and sectarian violence ... must be brought to an end, from whichever part of the community they come. We need to see an immediate, full and permanent cessation of all paramilitary activity, including military attacks, training, targeting, intelligence gathering, acquisition or development of arms or weapons, other preparations for terrorist campaigns, punishment beatings and attacks and involvement in riots. Moreover, the practice of exiling must come to an end and the exiled must feel free to return in safety. Similarly, sectarian attacks and intimidation directed at vulnerable communities must cease.”

Alliance believes that the above standard should be incorporated into the Pledge of Office.

Review of Public Administration

The current Review of Public Administration does not address the responsibilities of the 11 Government Departments. Alliance believes it is essential that the separate Review of the Agreement recommends a reduction of government bureaucracy at this level first, before the Review of Public Administration agrees changes at lower levels.

Northern Ireland is over governed relative to comparative areas elsewhere in these islands. This is compounded by the unnecessary and expensive duplication of facilities.

The structures for the administration of health and education are clearly identified as some of those most in need of reform.

A number of principles will guide the Alliance approach to the Review of Public Administration:

First, public bodies must be responsive to the needs of communities. Alliance sees a role for a range of regional, sub-regional and local bodies. Services should be delivered as close to the people concerned while taking into account efficiency and effectiveness.

Second, the reform of public bodies should take on board the need to promote integration and better community relations. Administrative boundaries should not be created so as to reinforce separation in society, but rather to promote mixing of people.

Third, reform of public administration must be governed by pragmatism rather than ideology. Alliance will not take an ideological position in favour of either the use of the public or the private sector, but will support whatever approach is the most appropriate for delivering the best quality services in each circumstance.

Wider Relations

Alliance will promote Northern Ireland as a distinct region within a devolving British Isles, and an evolving Europe of the regions. 19th century notions of sovereignty are no longer appropriate in the early 21st century. Although Northern Ireland remains part of the United Kingdom, it should be encouraged to develop a range of relationships with the Republic of Ireland, as well as with Scotland, Wales, the English regions and the Crown dependencies of the British Isles. Furthermore, Northern Ireland should increasingly develop its links with Europe and North America.

Alliance is a strongly pro-European party. We have an excellent record of participation in wider European and international debates through our membership of the European Liberal Democratic and Reform (ELDR) Party, and Liberal International.


Northern Ireland remains a deeply divided society. But rather than these communal divisions being addressed and overcome, they are becoming institutionalised.

Sectarianism and segregation remain major scars on Northern Ireland, and have even intensified in recent years.

Sectarian attitudes are not restricted to those in and around interfaces, but permeate throughout society. Sectarianism is about prejudice, scapegoating, and putting people into boxes.

The dominant view, both from the Agreement and many aspects of Government policy, is that Northern Ireland is permanently divided into separate Protestant/Unionist and Catholic/Nationalist communities.

The state caters to these `separate communities' with needlessly duplicating facilities, wasting resources that could otherwise be used to improve the quality of services.

Yet there is substantial evidence that a clear majority of the people in Northern Ireland would like to have mixed facilities in which to live, to work, and to be educated. Almost a quarter of Protestants and a third of Catholics do not wish to be described as either Unionist or Nationalist. Furthermore, the 2001 Census showed that 14% of the population do not wish to be described as either Protestant or Catholic.

Skilful conflict management of a so-called `benign apartheid' cannot be sustained. With little or no common bonds, it is relatively easy for `separate communities' to go their different ways with any major crisis.

The healing of our communal divisions must be the greatest priority for our political institutions, and thus lies at the heart of Alliance's policy agenda.

Alliance priorities for the next four years in the Assembly are to—

Equality

Alliance will promote equality of opportunity, equality of treatment, equality of access, and equality under the law for all people, irrespective of:

We are opposed to all forms of unlawful and unfair discrimination. To this end, Alliance makes the following pledges—


Alliance favours a mixed economy, in which a primacy of market solutions is balanced by a government and public concern for social justice. The role of government, especially with the onset of a knowledge-driven economy, should be to create the right framework conditions for a dynamic and high-growth economy.

A successful economy and prosperity are essential to creating the favourable conditions for the development of a shared, non-sectarian society, and giving people a stake in the consolidation of peace.

The economy of Northern Ireland is our own responsibility. We must stand on our own financial feet. What is required is a change of attitude.

We need to encourage entrepreneurship and applaud local success stories. We need to be positive and outward-looking, with confidence in our abilities and skills. We need a `can-do' culture that focuses on results.

We must give greater recognition for the increasingly vital role women have in our economy. This includes removing social barriers to their promotion to upper management, and delivering equal pay. Alliance is confident in the abilities and skills of men and women, equally.

Our economy will be driven forward by private business. Government can encourage this by removing structural obstacles. Our vision must be modernised:

Alliance priorities for the next four years in the Assembly are to—

Energy

A sustainable energy policy is needed for Northern Ireland, one that aims to maximise energy efficiency and minimise consumption of non-renewable resources. Consumers of energy should become more aware of the true economic and environmental costs of their consumption. Tax and subsidy regimes should be altered accordingly to better reflect the `polluter pays' principle.

Agriculture and Rural Development

Northern Ireland contains many rural communities that are reliant on the agri-food industry, providing employment and a valuable contribution to our Gross Domestic Product.

Like any other sector, the forces of modernisation and globalisation cannot be ignored or wished away. Alliance will provide the leadership to face these challenges and more, to ensure the vitality and success of our food and drink industries.

Change will also occur from EU and UK-wide legislation. Alliance will assist farmers more in adjusting to new policies, and we will provide an adequate timescale for change.


Sectarianism costs us money, not only in dealing with its violent manifestations, but in everyday life. The `separate but equal' mindset requires duplicate facilities in our education, health and social services. This wastes money that could be used to improve the quality of services for us all. Addressing sectarianism, first and foremost, could generate the greatest savings in public expenditure.

Alliance accepts that the Executive has only limited financial resources at its disposal. The windfall from the Chancellor of the Exchequer and the continuation of European Structural Funds until 2006 reflects a somewhat artificial position. In the long term, the Barnett Formula erodes the advantages in public expenditure of the Northern Ireland Administration. Therefore, there is a responsibility upon the Executive to spend resources wisely, to invest in the future, and to prioritise addressing the causes (rather than the immediate symptoms) of problems.

Any reform will require phasing in over a number of years, and Alliance would embark upon negotiations with key stakeholders.

Alliance priorities for the next four years in the Assembly are to—


Alliance is fully committed to the highest standards of justice and the rule of law. We believe that there is a fundamental relationship between democracy, human rights, and the rule of law. The Agreement has not been the source of the law and order problems in Northern Ireland. These problems have persisted and developed despite the Agreement. Alliance believes that the platform of the Agreement provides the best means for asserting the primacy of the rule of law, democracy, and a Bill of Rights.

Our vision of policing in Northern Ireland is of a single, integrated, professional police service that is representative of, responsive to, and carrying the confidence of the entire community. Alliance gives its full support to the Police Service of Northern Ireland in upholding the rule of law. A key element of this new beginning must be an increasingly community-based approach, which will re-enforce the needs of the community.

Action is required at a number of levels:

Alliance priorities for the next four years in the Assembly are to—

Structures and Resources

Enforcement and Revision of the Criminal Law

A Culture of Lawfulness

Human Rights

As a longstanding supporter of human rights, Alliance believes that Northern Ireland should have the best set of human rights protections possible. These could, in turn, be a model for other parts of these islands and Europe. Alliance welcomes the passage of the Human Rights Act, and supports efforts of the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission (NIHRC) to draft a Bill of Rights for Northern Ireland.

Victims

Alliance will work to help our society move beyond a `hierarchy of victims', in order to ensure that those who have suffered throughout the community are supported in an inclusive way. We recognise the tensions in acknowledging all victims in our society, thus commit ourselves to strategies that strive to unite our community (see separate manifesto section, `Building a United Community').